Older diabetes patients are often overtreated
Several studies have found that older patients with diabetes are often overtreated – meaning that they are taking more medications, or medications at too high doses, than they need to achieve a safe level of sugar control.
Recently, we reported that doctors deintensified medications for only a quarter of nearly 25,000 older patients with diabetes who were treated to potentially dangerously low levels of sugar control. Deintensification rates barely budged even if the patient has had low blood sugar multiple times or had severely limited life expectancy.
In patients with low blood sugar who did not have their treatment deintensified, 40% did not even have their diabetes control values rechecked within six months. This means that the majority of overtreated patients continued to take medications that they did not need or at doses that were too high.
Why don’t clinicians deintensify treatment?
Doctors usually focus on intensifying therapy to control blood sugar, which means that deintensifying treatment can take a completely new mindset.
In another study, we asked primary care providers what they thought would be appropriate treatment for a hypothetical patient in his late 70’s who has had diabetes for 20 years and also has kidney disease. The patient takes two pills every day to manage his diabetes, but could be fine just taking one of them. We found that 39% of almost 600 respondents felt that this patient would continue to benefit from stringent diabetes control – despite current expert recommendations to the contrary.
When we looked at reasons why, 42% of providers worried that not treating him intensively could harm the scores on their clinical report cards, which track the quality of care the doctors’ provide to their patients. Nearly one-quarter worried about legal liability resulting from decreasing medications.
Just as troubling, 30% wouldn’t deintensify the diabetes medications because they worried they wouldn’t have enough time to discuss these changes with the patient.